Defense questions search of pickup bed in Buscema murder trial
A 357 SIG handgun found in the truck bed two weeks ago has raised questions about the initial police investigation.
By Scott Marshall ·

A 357 SIG handgun sat in the bed of a Toyota Tacoma for nearly two and a half years before it was found. The weapon belonged to Vincent Buscema Sr., who is currently on trial for the murder of his son, Vincent Buscema Jr. The discovery occurred just two weeks ago, long after the June 9, 2024, shooting that led to the elder Buscema's arrest.
Defense attorney Chris Dodd raised the issue during cross-examination of Rio Rancho Police Detective Arion Hayes on Wednesday, Nov. 18. Hayes, the lead investigator, presented the handgun to the jury. He stated that Buscema Sr. had admitted to owning the gun. Dodd countered that the weapon was located by a private investigator hired by the defense, not by the police.
Hayes testified that the truck bed, which had been removed from the home, was searched on the day of the shooting. The search took place after the defendant was taken to the police station. When pressed by Dodd, Hayes admitted the search was not as thorough as he would have liked. He also confirmed that the cover to the bed was not locked.
The defense raised additional questions about physical evidence at the scene. Investigators confirmed two casings from Buscema Sr's gun and seven from a 9mm handgun owned by Buscema Jr. Testimony revealed that the Ford pickup owned by the son had multiple bullet holes. Despite the damage, the vehicle was not sealed or taken into evidence by investigators.
Prosecutors played video from the initial interview of Buscema Sr. after his arrest. They also presented text messages exchanged between the father and son leading up to the shooting. The messages on both phones were identical. They detailed a heated dispute, with Buscema Sr. writing, "Tough guy. I'll come you're not running your mouth now big boy I'm looking for you."
The prosecution rested its case on Thursday. Buscema was arrested on the day of the shooting and later charged with murder after his son died on July 8, 2024. If convicted, Buscema faces a prison sentence of up to 20 years.
More News · Rio Rancho news · Report a business · Got a Story?






