Letby legal team seeks urgent appeal after expert witness restrictions revealed
Lucy Letby’s lawyer has requested an urgent review of her convictions after it was revealed that a key prosecution expert was barred from clinical practice for safety reasons during the trial.
By News Media House Staff ·

Lucy Letby’s legal team has urged the court of appeal to urgently review her convictions following the disclosure that a key prosecution witness had been barred from treating patients due to safety concerns. The revelation centers on Professor Peter Hindmarsh, a medical expert who testified that two babies were poisoned with insulin during the trial.
It emerged this week that Professor Hindmarsh was excluded from clinical practice in March 2023 because his hospital deemed him unsafe to treat children in relation to insulin. This restriction was not disclosed to the defense or the jury, who heard him described as a pre-eminent expert in the field.
Mark McDonald, Letby’s lawyer, has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission for her convictions to be referred back to the court of appeal. He stated that the failure to disclose material information about the witness raises fundamental questions about the safety of the convictions. McDonald emphasized that Letby is serving whole-life sentences for crimes where critical evidence was withheld from her defense.
The defense was not informed of the exclusion nor of an April 2023 tribunal ruling that imposed supervision requirements on Hindmarsh. The Crown Prosecution Service has also confirmed it was not aware of these developments. Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others, resulting in 15 whole-life terms.
Since the initial convictions, numerous medical and scientific experts have supported the application, arguing that the prosecution’s medical case was flawed. A recent investigation revealed that while the trial was ongoing at Manchester crown court, Hindmarsh’s employer reported to the General Medical Council that he posed a risk to child patients.
Dr Tim Hodgson, a medical director at University College London hospitals trust, wrote to the GMC in March 2023 stating that the hospital could not allow Hindmarsh to practice clinically due to safety grounds. He cited specific cases where Hindmarsh had advised child patients to stop taking insulin, contributing to the decision to restrict his clinical work.
Although a medical practitioners tribunal declined to suspend Hindmarsh’s registration in April 2023, it ordered direct supervision for his clinical work. However, this appeared to have no practical effect because his employer had already barred him from treating patients entirely. The jury was never told about the GMC investigation or the termination of his contract at Great Ormond Street hospital in July 2022.
The lead prosecution barrister had described Hindmarsh to the jury as the pre-eminent expert in the narrow field of insulin. Legal experts note that criminal procedure rules require witnesses to disclose any disciplinary proceedings that might undermine their opinion or credibility. These rules were introduced in 2014 to prevent miscarriages of justice.
Specialists in criminal disclosure suggest that the non-disclosure of material undermining an expert’s opinion could form grounds for an appeal, particularly when that evidence is central to the jury’s verdict. The situation echoes the case of Sally Clark, whose conviction was overturned in 2003 after key medical evidence was found to be flawed and undisclosed to the defense.
A representative for Professor Hindmarsh declined to answer questions about whether he disclosed the March and April developments to Cheshire constabulary. The police force also declined to comment, while the prosecution confirmed it never received the information regarding the expert’s clinical restrictions.
Originally published by News Media House






